• News

    • Politics
  • Entertainment

    • TV
    • Movies
    • Books
    • Music
    • Celebrity
  • Sports

  • Relationships

    • Moms
    • Weddings
    • Sex
    • Dating
  • Lifestyle

    • Internet Culture
    • Travel
    • Wellness
    • Food
    • Astrology
    • Careers
  • Style

    • Fashion
    • Beauty
    • Shopping
  • Instagram
    X
    TikTok
    YouTube
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Do Not Sell My Info
  • Meet Us
  • Podcasts
  • Newsletters
  • Careers
  • Culture
  • Advertise
  • Topics A-Z
  • Authors
  • Archive
Instagram
X
TikTok
YouTube
Submit Your Content
…Is ‘The Idea Of You’ Fact Or Fiction?

Home> Entertainment

Updated 14:11 13 Mar 2026 GMTPublished 18:10 29 Apr 2024 GMT+1

…Is ‘The Idea Of You’ Fact Or Fiction?

Revisiting my 2014 1D fanfic.

Ilana Frost

Ilana Frost

google discoverFollow us on Google Discover
Featured Image Credit: Getty

Topics: Movies, One Direction

Ilana Frost
Ilana Frost

Ilana Frost is an entertainment writer at Betches. As a teenage girl in her twenties, she spends her time stanning Olivia Rodrigo, baking cakes for award shows, and refusing to ever leave her Reputation era.

Advert

Advert

Advert

Every Directioner is aware that The Idea of You is coming out on Amazon Prime on May 2. It’s marked on our calendars. Tattooed on our brains. We have nostalgia boy band playlists to help prepare ourselves. Why? Because the movie, based on Robinne Lee’s 2017 novel of the same name, is about a popular boy band, August Moon, with a hot lead singer who pursues an older woman. And I think I’ve heard that story somewhere before. Ah, yes — because it sounds like one of the main events of recent pop culture history.

One Direction lived from 2010 to 2016 and remains the most important boy band phenomenon of the century and the most important thing to happen in my life in general. It’s no wonder social media users, authors, and filmmakers continue to be inspired by the British icons. When we first heard about The Idea of You plot and saw the trailer, a lot of us 1D fans jumped to understandable conclusions. So, is The Idea of You actually based on a true (One Direction) story?

Is The Idea Of You Based On A True Story?

The short answer is technically no. Despite the major fanfic energy of The Idea of You, the author of the novel did not base her story on fans’ wild ideas. The heartthrob character Hayes is supposed to be a new fictional creation, so we’re not looking at a Harry biopic here. Robinne explained to Vogue that the story is about Anne’s character, Solène, “a woman approaching 40 and reclaiming her sexuality and rediscovering herself, just at the point that society traditionally writes women off as desirable and viable and whole.” Yes… I’d say it’s about that and One Direction.

Was The Idea Of You Inspired By One Direction And Harry Styles?

One Direction
One Direction
Image Credit: Getty

Advert

It’s strikingly obvious to everyone that there are plenty of One Direction and Harry references in this film. In The Idea of You, August Moon has five members and a tatted Brit lead singer who has a preference for dating older women. Plus, they got One Direction songwriters Carl Folk and Savan Kotecha to write music for the movie, sooo it’s more than fair to compare August Moon to 1D and Hayes to Harry.

Although Robinne has said that she didn’t base her book on a true story, she has admitted that 1D and Harry inspired her. While chatting with Vogue, she called Hayes a “Prince Harry-meets-Harry [Styles]” figure and revealed that she wrote The Idea of You after enjoying lots of Harry YouTube videos. Basically, The Idea of You would probably be a very different film without the existence of the 1D boys and Harry’s juicy love life.

Choose your content:

12 days ago
14 days ago
19 days ago
  • Getty Images
    12 days ago

    Life Dream Achieved: Chatting with Rachel Sennott & Jordan Firstman About ‘I Love LA’ Season 2

    Just a casual chat with my parasocial besties.

    Entertainment
  • Getty Images
    14 days ago

    Bieberchella’s Karaoke Set Healed an Entire Generation

    Justin Bieber could whisper “baby” in a hoodie and I’d call it art.

    Entertainment
  • HBO
    14 days ago

    On The Pitt, Dr. Al-Hashimi Makes One Thing Clear: She’s in Charge

    She doesn’t raise her voice—she raises the stakes.

    Entertainment
  • Bravo
    19 days ago

    Please Don't Talk to Me Unless It's About 'RHORI'

    Oh how I’ve missed watching Ashley I. cry on my TV screen.

    Entertainment
  • Louis Tomlinson Talks 1D Breakup & Liam Payne’s Death In Emotional ‘Diary Of A CEO’ Interview
  • Zayn Malik Speaks Out About Racism He Faced During The 1D Era In New Rap Song
  • These ‘Idea of You’ Tweets Are Making Me Fall More In Love With Nicholas Galitzine
  • Hayes In ‘The Idea Of You’ Is Supposed To Be Harry Styles, Correct?