Image Credit: Getty

We Urgently Need To Discuss Ayo Edebiri's Juicy Dating History

There have been a lot of rumors about Ayo Edebiri’s dating life recently. Why? Probably because this queen surrounds herself with the most sickeningly stunning men in the entertainment biz. Jeremy Allen White may be 5’7″, but he has my heart, and Paul Mescal may have had a mullet once, but he has my soul. Ayo herself is obviously gorgeous, and people love to ship hot people with hot people — it’s just a fact of pop culture. As I prepare to binge season 3 of The Bear in roughly one to two sittings, it feels appropriate to stalk her and investigate these romance rumors myself.

So, is Ayo single these days? Dating her Calvin Klein model costar or another actor? Let’s quell these curiosities together: Here’s Ayo Edebiri’s complete dating history and current relationship status.

Ayo Edebiri Full Dating History

Colin Burgess

In September 2023, fans on Twitter were unpleasantly surprised to discover that Ayo was taken. Apparently, she’s dating or previously dated actor and writer Colin Burgess. Although they’ve kept their relationship mostly private, social media detectives stumbled upon a February 2021 Instagram post where Colin calls Ayo his “girlfriend.” He posted a very couple-y selfie of him and Ayo wearing sheet masks and wrote, “after much consideration I have decided that this year my valentine is my girlfriend Ayo. this is a photo of us together doing Dr. Jart+ Water Jet Vital Hydra Solution™ sheet mask.”

Fans in love with Ayo were so fucking pissed that Colin’s buddy, Fire Island star Joel Kim Booster, had to come to his defense. “I’ve known Ayo’s boyfriend for close to a decade and he is such a kind, smart, funny dude and y’all are being weird as shit,” he wrote in a since-deleted Tweet. “Log off and make a real human friend I’m begging you.” To clarify, he wrote this in September 2023, so we don’t know if Ayo and Colin are still dating now.

Paul Mescal

Paul Mescal and Ayo Edebiri
Image Credit: Getty

The internet lost its mind after Ayo posted an Instagram Story with Paul that literally could’ve been a hard launch. In the photo, both actors are laughing, Paul’s blushing and has a hand on his head, and Ayo is latched onto his shoulder. She captioned it, “Happy St. Paddy’s 🍀.” Okay, this post was probably just a reference to the ongoing joke about Ayo being an Irish queen, but… they really teased us with this.

A source then confirmed to People that they’re “just friends” for now. Rude.

Is Ayo Edebiri Dating Jeremy Allen White?

Ayo Edebiri and Jeremy Allen White
Image Credit: Getty

Devastatingly, we don’t know exactly what her relationship status is. Girl could still be with Colin, she could be secretly moving on to Paul, she could definitely be single, or… she could be striking up a romance with her The Bear costar, Jeremy Allen White. Their chemistry is obviously off the charts, and Ayo gushed about their connection to Vanity Fair in May

“Work can be a very intimate thing and a very personal thing and a very emotional thing,” she told the magazine. “Also, boy’s got some beautiful blue eyes. You know what I mean? Those are eyes you want to project onto.” Yes, Ayo! We know exactly what you mean, and we support it.

Ilana Frost
Ilana Frost
Ilana Frost is an entertainment writer at Betches. As a teenage girl in her twenties, she spends her time stanning Olivia Rodrigo, baking cakes for award shows, and refusing to ever leave her Reputation era.