Go back

Not Another True Crime

Betches Media presents a podcast for people who love all types of sketchy things—from cults to conspiracy theories to, of course, crime—with a healthy dose of irreverent humor. Each week, Sara Levine and Danny Murphy give the lowdown on one morbidly fascinating topic. They’ll present the facts of each case, punctuated with jokes and side tangents, along with their own personal theories. For more things true crime, follow us on Instagram @natcpod.

View Promo Codes

Latest Episodes

Our Hosts

Sara Levine

Sara Levine is the Editor-in-Chief of Betches and the co-host of Not Another True Crime Podcast. Her hobbies are whichever season of Real Housewives she’s watching.

Danny Murphy

Danny Murphy is a comedian and coffee drinker who hosts Not Another True Crime Podcast for Betches. He also can be heard every Wednesday as the resident pop culture host on Sirius XM’s Bennington and is the host/creator of the digital series Venti Vents: where caffeinating meets complaining.

Where to Start

BREAKING UPDATES: Alex Murdaugh, Elizabeth Holmes, and Maura Murray

Sara and Danny are back yet again with another special emergency with some wild updates on a few cases! They cover the latest in the Murdaugh murders, including some crucial updates in Alex’s shooting; some bizarre details of the ongoing case against Elizabeth Holmes; and a potential new discovery of evidence near where Maura Murray went missing. Don’t forget to follow us @notanothertruecrime for ongoing updates! SOURCES: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/14/us/alex-murdaugh-shooting-arrest.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/06/us/alex-murdaugh-murders-law-firm.html https://www.npr.org/2021/09/14/1036835868/elizabeth-holmes-trial-hotelier-bill-evans-goes-incognito https://boston.cbslocal.com/2021/09/14/maura-murray-missing-woman-new-hampshire-state-police-bone-fragments-loon-mountain/ https://www.yahoo.com/news/death-murdaugh-housekeeper-fell-home-212700951.html https://www.cnn.com/2021/09/16/us/murdaugh-shooting-arrest-thursday/index.html

The Disappearance Of Heather Elvis

Sara and Danny dive into a case that takes place in South Carolina, Heather Elvis’ mysterious disappearance. They break down the circumstances surrounding the night she vanished and then get into the likeliest suspects and what we know about what could’ve happened to her. They also talk all about the court cases that have followed and their outcomes. To end the show, they take inspiration from the restaurant Heather worked at, The Tilted Kilt, and try to find the best restaurant name in America! Be sure to follow @notanothertruecrime to vote for your pick and stay up to date on all things crime.

The Death Of Leslie Neulander

Sara and Danny dive into the as-of-yet undetermined cause of the death of Leslie Neulander. Although we always say ‘it was the husband’, and Dr. Robert Neulander has been accused and convicted of her murder, he has always maintained his innocence and a retrial is expected to take place early 2022. Was her death an unfortunate accident, or murder? To end the show, they play a game of “My Health Care Plan Is Not Getting Sick!,” where they attempt to correctly answer a series of questions about the convoluted and ridiculous health care industry in the US. SOURCES: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/accident-or-murder-48-hours-investigates-death-of-leslie-neulander/ https://www.syracuse.com/crime/2021/02/six-years-after-first-robert-neulander-trial-murder-retrial-hits-yet-another-snag.html https://www.syracuse.com/crime/2021/08/robert-neulanders-murder-retrial-bumped-again-new-date-is-nearly-a-decade-after-wifes-death.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/10/31/nyregion/robert-neulander-wife-murdered.html https://cnycentral.com/news/local/neulanders-second-chance-the-death-of-his-wife-a-media-circus-and-now-a-new-trial

Our Reviews


Love you guys so much. The content and commentary is spot on. I love crime but I neeeed the comedy mixed in because I’m a Scorpio and my only sense of humor is dark.

Like catching up with friends

Every Monday I listen to NATCP and I feel like I am catching up with friends talking about crime and conspiracies over coffee.


It’s —-not another—- true crime podcast! It’s not the same as others (which I also like). This is TRULY like doing a rundown of a case with your friends sitting around. The hosts are great and hilarious! The fan base is as well.

Recent Guests

Adam Brody
Nancy Grace
Harlan Coben

All Podcasts

Podcasts that cut the sh*t

View Promo Codes

Betches Co-Founders Aleen Dreksler, Jordana Abraham, and Sami Sage are taking you on the journey of how Betches came to be and inside the minds of the women who created it. From their awkward middle school years to founding Betches and beyond, get to know the women who've been making us laugh since 2011.

U Up?

From interpreting dating app messages and weird sexual encounters, to defining the relationship and everything in between, we’re here to make sure you don’t die alone. 

Diet Starts Tomorrow
Diet Starts Tomorrow

In a world where “wellness” looks perfect on Instagram but feels anything but in real life, Diet Starts Tomorrow explores the psychological and emotional sides of wellbeing, from people who understand the struggle.

Betches Moms

Get ready to lock yourself in the bathroom (or wherever else you hide from your kids) and listen to this podcast. Because you’ll literally never be alone again.

The Betchelor

We’re here to say all the things you're screaming at your TV while watching The Bachelor—because that finale dress was disgusting!

Betches Sup

Be informed, not bored. Five days a week, rotating cohosts run through the wildest headlines and offer analysis and commentary that will make you actually laugh out loud.

Not Another True Crime

Your two funniest friends talking about crime. Each week, we break down a crime, cult, scam, or scheme with a healthy dose of irreverent humor.

Mention It All

Bravo, Bravo, f*cking Bravo. Three times a week, we break down everything Real Housewives and more, from episode recaps to social media drama.

Morning Announcements

Every morning, Betches co-founder and host Sami Sage gives you quick daily updates with the most important info you need to know about politics and current events.

Betches Brides

With tips on how to secure the best vendors, deal with your suffocating future mother-in-law, and everything in between, we’re here for you from the moment they put a ring on it until after you walk down the aisle. 

Afternoon Tea

Your weekly dose of the political therapy we all desperately need right now!

Pop Alarm
Pop Alarm

From breaking celebrity stories to the latest in music, movies, and TV, Pop Alarm will make you feel pop cultured in five minutes or less.